Nick Carter can Sing Anything – A Compilation of Covers (Part 2)

by | May 3, 2024 | Backstreet Boys, BSB Army, History, Music, Nick Carter, Playlist, Solo Music, Throwback, Who I Am Tour | 0 comments

A few months back, I was thinking about Nick Carter’s upcoming #WhoIAm tour stop in Niagara, where I got to see the show live. If you haven’t seen it, Nick mixed in some of his original songs along with several classic hits in an unforgettable set list. Knowing he planned to do some covers, I put together a compilation of some of the most memorable Nick Carter covers I could remember.

But here’s the thing…there’s more. And they are all amazing.

A brilliant mind asked recently on Twitter/X if there were any songs we would want to see Nick add to his setlist. And the fans delivered with one of the most eclectic list of possible options. Some of them, Nick has already sang, and those are either here NICK CARTER CAN SING ANYTHING Part 1, or below in this post.

Beyond that, you’ll find a list of songs that Nick hasn’t covered yet, at least not publicly, which we will now PLEAD to have added to some set list somewhere that NIck will sing some day. #AGirlCanDream!

With or Without You (U2) (Mixed with I Got You)

LoveSong (The Cure)

Sharp Dressed Man (ZZ Top)

Bleeding Love (Leona Lewis)

I Don’t Wanna Miss a Thing (Aerosmith)

Alone (Heart)

Hey @NickCarter! Could you take a look at these fan suggested covers that you can add to your set list?? Pretty Please??? I’m partial to 311 Amber, myself. 🙂

Amber (311)

Dream On (Aerosmith)

Falling Away From Me (Korn)

I’ll Be (Edwin McCain)

Don’t Dream It’s Over (Crowded House)

Take On Me (A-Ha)

Nothing Compares 2 U (Sinead O’Connor)

Always (Bon Jovi)

Make Me Bad (Korn)

Numb (Linkin Park)

Fly Away (Lenny Kravitz)

How am I Supposed to Live Without You (Michael Bolton)

Creep (Stone Temple Pilots)

Livin on a Prayer (Bon Jovi)

Against All Odds (Phil Collins)

Careless Whisper (Seether)

You’re the Inspiration (Chigago)

Sex and Candy (Marcy’s Playground)

All out of Love (Air Supply)

Sweet Child o’ Mine (Guns N’ Roses)

Scars (Papa Roach)

Down with Sickness (Disturbed)

Broken (Seether)

Feed My Frankenstein (Alice in Chains)

Pretty Fly (for a white guy) (Offspring)

Closer (Ne-Yo)

And I Love Her (The Beatles)

Eye of the Tiger (Survivor)

Lips of an Angel (Hinder)

Stellar (Incubus)

Still Remains (Stone Temple Pilots)

Nothings Gonna Change My Love For You (George Benson)

Bed of Roses (Bon Jovi)

The Moment of Truth (Survivor)

I’ll Do Anything for Love (Meatloaf)

Break Me, Shake Me (Savage Garden)

Sunshine (Alice in Chains)

It is Any Wonder (Durand Jones and the Indications)

Feel (Robbie Williams)

Simple Men (Lynryd Skinner)

Sex on Fire (Kings of Leon)

One (U2)

You May Be Right (Billy Joel)

Creep (Radiohead)

In the End (Linkin Park)

More than a Feeling (Boston)

Summer of ’69 (Bryan Adams)

Keep the Faith (Bon Jovi)

Shameless (Garth Brooks)

Stay with Me (Sam Smith)

NICK CARTER CAN SING ANYTHING Part 1 includes NIck Carter’s covers of:

Wanted Dead or Alive (Bon Jovi)

Right Here Waiting for You (Richard Marx)

Toxic (Britney Spears)

Nights in White Satin (Moody Blues)

Heaven (Bryan Adams)

Faithfully (Journey)

Free Fallin (Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers)

Just What I Needed (The Cars)

Wonderwall (Oasis)

Pony (Ginuwine)

No Diggity (Backstreet Boys cover of Blackstreet)

Dreams (Fleetwood Mac)

It’s My Life (Bon Jovi)

Addicted to Love (Robert Palmer)

Uptown Funk (Nick Carter on Drums with AJ Mclean covering Bruno Mars)

Open Arms (Journey)

Ordinary World (Duran Duran)

On Bended Knee (Nick Carter with the AFTR Party covering Boyz II Men)

I’ll Make Love to You (Nick Carter with the AFTR Party covering Boyz II Men)

End of the Road (Nick Carter with the AFTR Party covering Boyz II Men)

Make sure to check out Part 1!

Did we miss any songs that you’d like to see Nick Cover?

About Us

We are a group of women who love and support the Backstreet Boys. We are professionals in various aspects of business with backgrounds in marketing, journalism, writing, and psychology. 


Tweet Us

Blog Stats

  • 348,950 hits + 903,491 previously
Visit Our Shops!